Performance pay sends salaries into higher orbit
Execs' rewards overshadow raises given typical worker
By David Milstead
Rocky Mountain News
Saturday, June 7, 2008
Executive pay continues to increase at a pace far beyond the
raises typical workers see in their paychecks.
Last year, the median compensation figure for the 50 best-paid Colorado executives was
$7.66 million, a jump of 25 percent from 2006's $6.11 million.
By contrast, the average wage in
in 2007 was roughly $45,000, the Rocky estimates, about 3.5
percent above 2006's figure.
The Rocky tallies pay for this annual survey by counting salary,
bonus and other cash payments, plus the value of restricted
shares and other long-term compensation plans that are based on
the company's stock. Then, we add stock option profits from the
This year's survey captures a shift in the way companies are
paying their leaders. There's a growing emphasis on
performance-based stock awards. Stock options, previously
the favored form of incentive compensation, are becoming a
less-important part of the executive pay package.
In past years, "shareholders embraced options as a way of
aligning management's and shareholders' interests;
companies embraced them because of their (previously) favorable
accounting treatment," said Shirley Westcott, managing director
of policy at shareholder-advisory firm Proxy Governance.
(The cost of options didn't have to be reflected anywhere in the
company's income statement, so it was like giving away free
But, companies needed to issue millions of shares of stock when
the options were exercised, so existing shareholders' stakes got
"And options can also create perverse incentives -- bolstering
the share price in the short-term to exercise options," Westcott
As stock prices collapsed in the early part of this decade, many
investors began to sour on options. The Financial
Accounting Standards Board then required companies to begin
expensing options in 2006, and the shift toward new forms of
compensation was on.
Compensation consulting firm Mercer found that among America's 350 biggest
revenue-producing companies, long-term performance-based plans
were nearly as common as stock options in 2007 compensation.
Studies by comp consultants Watson Wyatt and Frederic W. Cook &
Co. came to similar conclusions.
"If you look at some of the numbers, it's almost a flat-footed
tie," said Donald Sagolla, a Los Angeles-based consultant with
Mercer. "It's not that options are going away. The
higher up you get, the more you really want the feet to the fire
for specific performance."
Still, there is skepticism about the shift. Few believe
these new pay plans will reverse the longstanding expansion of
executive pay, even if companies turn in mediocre performance.
"More of these stock awards are dependent on meeting performance
targets than are option awards, and more are performance-related
than at any time in the past," said Paul Hodgson of The
Corporate Library, a Portland, Maine-based research firm that's
often critical of pay and governance practices. "But in
many cases, the performance required to vest in them is not as
challenging as shareholders would expect."
Perhaps no company better illustrates the shift to performance-ased
pay than Liberty Global, an owner of international
cable-television systems spun off from John Malone's Liberty
Media in 2004.
All five Liberty Global executives named in the company's
compensation disclosure are among
Colorado's 10 best-paid executives for
2007, thanks entirely to a new stock-based incentive plan the
company implemented last year.
The value of awards under Liberty Global's senior executive
performance incentive plan last year ranged from $30 million to
$55 million for each of the officers, with CEO Michael Fries
getting the biggest grant. The plan could pay even more
when it concludes next year, the company says.
According to Liberty Global's disclosure, its board used a
compensation consultant in late 2006 to conclude that Fries'
total possible pay, which included a stock option award, was
below the 25th percentile for the company's peers and "was no
To retain Fries and the other top managers, the company created
the incentive plan, setting aside $313.5 million in maximum
possible awards. Just 13 participants are eligible for
$302.5 million of that. Fries has a maximum possible award
of $64 million. Participants in the plan received no other
options or stock awards in 2007, and they will not receive any
this year, the company said.
Liberty Global will measure operating cash flow growth -- "the
primary measure used by our board and management to evaluate our
operating performance," the company explains to shareholders in
it most recent proxy. If it grows at a compound annual
rate of 12 percent for 2007 and 2008, adjusted for acquisitions,
the awards will begin to kick in. The maximum awards come
at 17 percent annual cash-flow growth. (The company said
it posted 2007 cash flow growth of 16.2 percent, adjusted
downward to reflect acquisitions.)
Liberty Global structured the plan to prevent executives from
immediately walking away in 2009 once the goals are met.
The company intends to pay out the awards in stock over the
three years from 2009 to 2011, but only if the executives stay
with the company.
Liberty Global spokesman Rick Westerman said, "The reported
stock awards for our executives include the present value of a
long-term incentive plan put in place in the second half of 2006
that compensates the team for superior operating performance
over a multiyear period. It's worth noting that our stock
price was up over 30 percent in calendar 2007 and up over 70
percent since the beginning of 2006, significantly outperforming
our peer group over both periods."
Past service rewarded
While Liberty Global's plan may represent the future of
executive compensation, many executives are still being rewarded
for past service.
Crocs CEO Ron Snyder made nearly $42 million by exercising Crocs
stock options in 2007. The company's shares rose during
2007 from $21.60, to $75, before settling in at $36.81.
Snyder's options, granted when Crocs was a private company,
typically had exercise prices of $1 or less. (Crocs stock
has subsequently sunk sharply, to below $10.)
At home builder MDC, shareholders got burned as the stock
declined over the year from $55.24 to $36.71. But the
company's longtime top two executives, CEO Larry Mizel and
President David Mandarich, each made more than $7 million by
exercising stock options granted years before.
"There is usually a timing difference between executive actions
that result in a rising stock price and the year that options
are exercised and option profits are taken," said Peter Miterko,
a consultant with Denver Management Advisors.
"It might take two or three years of executive effort to show up
in the stock price, and the executive may not exercise until
years after that, if the stock price stays buoyant," he said.
"Of course, the opposite is also true. Share price might
rise in a bull market, even if company performance is worse."
Lucrative years at end
The long-term power of options often means an executive's final
years are the most lucrative ones. Typically, the
executives exercise bunches of stock options given out over
multiple years. On top of that, they collect other types
of severance goodies.
Former Qwest CEO Richard Notebaert left the telco in early 2007,
but not before exercising $22.2 million in options. He also
received just over $8 million in severance pay.
Former Newmont Mining CEO Wayne Murdy made about $4 million in
option profits before his midyear retirement. His
compensation was boosted instead by $13.2 million in special
pension benefits, awarded as part of an employment agreement
that gave him extra service time if worked until he was 62.
You don't have to be a CEO to get this treatment, however.
Newmont gave former executive Vice President of Operations
Thomas Enos $9.25 million in pension benefits in his final year.
Finance Editor David Milstead can be reached at
milstead@RockyMountainNews.com or 303-954-2648.
By the numbers
Salaries of $1 million or more
* R. David Hoover, Ball Corp. chairman, president and CEO
* Gregory B. Maffei, Liberty Media president and CEO $1,000,000
* Larry A. Mizel, MDC Holdings chairman and CEO $1,000,000
Bonus and incentive pay of more than $2 million
* Gary D. Black, Janus Capital Group chief executive officer
* Jonathan D. Coleman, Janus Capital Group EVP and Co-CIO
* R. Gibson Smith, Janus Capital Group EVP and co-CIO $5,373,195
* Mark A. Hellerstein, St. Mary Land and Exploration former
president and CEO $3,885,668
* Ronald R. Snyder, Crocs president and CEO $3,200,000
* Gregory B. Maffei, Liberty Media president and CEO $2,650,000
* R. David Hoover, Ball Corp. chairman, president and CEO
* Larry A. Mizel, MDC Holdings chairman and CEO $2,000,000
* David D. Mandarich, MDC Holdings president and COO $2,000,000
* Leo Kiely, Molson Coors Brewing chief executive officer
Lots of options
Executives with option grants valued at $3 million or more
* Gregory B. Maffei, Liberty Media president and CEO $12,406,752
* Edward A. Mueller, Qwest chairman and CEO $8,602,400
* John C. Malone, Liberty Media chairman of the board (former
principal executive officer) $4,623,470
* Richard C. Notebaert, Qwest former chairman and CEO $4,548,370
* Ronald R. Snyder , Crocs president and CEO $3,925,390
* Charles Y. Tanabe, Liberty Media executive vice president,
secretary and general counsel $3,508,037
Executives who made more than $6 million from stock option
* Ronald R. Snyder , Crocs president and CEO $41,797,105
* Richard C. Notebaert, Qwest former chairman and CEO
* Shane O'Neill, Liberty Global senior vice president, chief
strategy officer $8,741,843
* Larry A. Mizel , MDC Holdings chairman and CEO $7,530,255
* David D. Mandarich, MDC Holdings president and COO $7,229,901
* Larissa L. Herda, Time Warner Telecom chairman, president, and
* Michael T. Fries, Liberty Global president and CEO $6,650,302
* F.H. Merelli, Cimarex Energy chairman, CEO and president
* David B. Christofferson, Venoco former CFO $6,186,271
Best-paid female executives
Their rank in relation to the Top 50
* 11. Larissa L. Herda, Time Warner Telecom chairman,
president and CEO $12,689,918
* 58. Robin C. Beery, Janus Capital Group EVP and chief
marketing officer $3,115,531
* 59. Dessa M. Bokides, ProLogis former CFO $3,056,009
* 71. Paula Kruger, Qwest executive vice president, mass
markets group $2,510,176
* 79. Martha D. Rehm, Vail Resorts former executive vice
president and general counsel $2,279,717
Glossary of terms
* Bonus: Bonuses used to be pretty simple - a cash
payment in addition to salary, almost always an award for the
company's prior-year performance. Now, companies also disclose
"non-equity incentive plan compensation." That is cash given to
an executive if the company uses a specific formula or
measurable goal to arrive at the amount given. If it's just a
bonus for good performance, it's still called a bonus.
* Stock options: Options allow the holder to buy a share
of stock for a specific price for a set period, often for 10
years. As the share price rises, the option is worth more.
* Restricted stock: The stock is "restricted" because the
executives who receive it can't call their broker and sell their
shares immediately. Instead, either time must pass or the
company has to hit a certain goal.
In the past, most restricted stock was "time-based," meaning an
executive just had to keep working for one to five years to get
the shares. Now, more and more companies are issuing
"performance-based" shares, which require the company to hit
certain financial targets, or "market-based" shares, which
require the company's stock price to appreciate.